TEXT ONLY VERSION
Local MissionEventsMinutesCommentsRelevant LinksCAP MembersSearchSite TreeHome
Brooklyn

CITIZEN ADVOCACY PANEL (CAP)

Brooklyn District Meeting Minutes

Date: January 18, 2001

Time: 6:00-9:30 PM

Location: 10 MetroTech Center, 625 Fulton Street, 6th Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Panel Members Attending:

  • Horace Aiken
  • Eileen Cain, acting DFO
  • Mercedes Cintron
  • Anthony Fandozzi
  • Burton Kahn
  • Edward Maher, Vice-Chairperson
  • John Rotondi
  • Matthew Mihovich
  • Ethel Richards

IRS Staff Attending:

  • Noemi Gonzalez
  • Gita Hecht

Absentees:

  • Jim Montes
  • Marie Nahikian
  • Laura Greenberg

Guests:

  • Mike Lewis, Treasury Liaison to CAP
  • Gail Ellis, National Office Communications
  • Ellen Murphy
  • George Deller
  • Gloria Goldberg
  • Public Attendees:
  • Joseph Noel
  • Marjorie Louer

Opening of the Meeting

Vice-Chairperson Maher opened the meeting at 6:15 PM.

Review of December 8, 2000 Minutes

The panel accepted the minutes as written.

Attendance Issue

Vice-Chair Maher stated that the chair had sent all panel members a letter indicating that he was stepping down as chairperson. Maher also indicated that he spoke to the panel member whose absences had been discussed at the last meeting. She indicated that it was her intention to remain on the panel while not attending meetings. She would try to attend tonight’s meeting to address her position on this issue. Maher sent her a letter confirming the intent of the panel to vote on whether or not to recommend her removal to Treasury. Since that discussion, the panel member has issued an e-mail indicating her intention to "resign" from the panel. Maher expressed his opinion that, since she did not intend to continue for the additional year, it should be left at that. A concern was raised if she should change her mind. It was decided that it that should occur, the panel would resume action on its vote.

Kristen Bailey, DFO, has been selected for another job. The CAP Manager, Eileen Cain, will act as DFO until a permanent replacement has been made for Kristen.

Procedures

There was a discussion of procedures for the election of officers. The term for officers needs to correspond to the term of panel members. It was decided to amend procedures to state that officers serve from the date of their election for one year or the end of their term on the panel, whichever is first.

The issue was raised that there is currently no chairperson. It was decided to elect a new chair and vice-chair now, for the one-year term. Panel member Mihovich made a motion to elect Ed Maher as Chair. Panel member Richards seconded this motion. The motion passed by a unanimous vote of panel members present. The floor was then opened for nominations for vice-chair. Panel member Mihovich nominated Tony Fandozzi; seconded by panel member Kahn. No additional candidates were nominated. Since there was only one candidate, a vote was taken. Panel member Fandozzi was elected by a unanimous vote of those present.

It was further suggested to make a change to page 1 of the procedures to change the number of absences to 3, to be consistent with Treasury’s document. This change was agreed to. Procedures accepted with the above changes. Further changes can be made as needed.

Video

Panel member Fandozzi introduced Gail Ellis, IRS Communications, and asked her to give her impression of the presentation he had just made to her regarding the educational video. Gail indicated that this is an excellent recommendation. It fits in with IRS initiatives to work on all walk-in sites. The IRS is trying to bring more uniformity to the set up of its sites. There are about 400 sites and currently only 20 have TVs. The timing of the proposal is very good. There are some issues about funding. Her function is user- funded meaning that a segment of the organization needs to fund the project. The funding issue needs to be resolved to get the project done.

Guests

It was noted that guests were present, including Joseph Noel, a CPA; and Marjorie Louer, former panel member. Introductions were made of everyone in the room for the benefit of the guests present.

Calendar for 2001

There was further discussion of the proposals for the meeting calendar. All panel members were in agreement that an expeditious resolution was needed. A calendar was agreed upon, a copy of which is attached.

Appreciation

Mike Lewis of Treasury was present at the meeting. He spoke briefly about the timeframes for bringing on new panel members, indicating that he anticipated it being June. He also spoke about his appreciation of the work the panel is doing. Plaques were distributed to each member, commemorating their two-year service.

Recruitment

CAP Manager Cain spoke about the recruitment efforts. She spoke about callers (either potential panel members or press) who might want information on what it is like to be a panel member. She indicated that she would like for panel members to respond to these callers and asked for volunteers. The following panel members volunteered: Fandozzi, Mihovich, Maher, Aiken, Kahn, Cintron, and Richards. Panel members will only speak to their own experiences. If the caller (particularly the press) needs further information, they can be referred. CAP Manager will provide panel members with names and phone numbers for referral.

Suggestion Subcommittee

Panel member Kahn spoke about several new suggestions:

  • The first suggestion was to include IRA charts that are in the pub 590 in two additional publications. These charts are 6-7 pages long. Acting DFO Cain indicated that there are new regulations for 2002 that are much simpler and will eliminate the need for these charts. CAP staff will inform the practitioner making the suggestion of these changes.
  • The second suggestion was in regard to indexing the Form 2441, Child Care Credit, to inflation. Panel member Kahn had already made this suggestion. It was noted that the new Congress already has a new piece of legislation on this issue. A letter will be written in support of this legislation.
  • As a result of a previous suggestion, panel member Kahn reviewed the package X with an eye towards eliminating unnecessary forms. As a result of his review, he is submitting a suggestion to the panel to eliminate the 1040A. The panel members will review his recommendation and discuss further at the next meeting. Staff will research usage of each of the forms in the 1040 series (1040, 1040A, and 1040EZ), as well as number of electronic returns submitted for each.
  • Questioned status of previous suggestion to declare penalties under $5 de minimus. The panel consensus is that this issue is not worth pursuing.

Small Business Subcommittee

Small Business Chairperson, Richards suggested that panel members look for listings in the paper of meetings of small business groups. Panel members should notify her of upcoming events. Her committee will follow up on these activities and try to arrange for CAP to attend and speak about the functions of the panel.

Additional Items

  • Panel member Kahn indicated that he has been distributing CAP material at VITA and AARP meetings.
  • Panel member Mihovich commented on the EITC notice the IRS issued regarding custody reported by states and its affect on claiming EITC. He noted that a it was a good, clear letter and if the IRS sent more like it, there would be fewer problems.
  • Panel member Mihovich had occasion to meet Senator Markowitz and would like to give him a copy of last year’s annual report. Staff to provide a copy.
  • Panel member Mihovich also indicated that he would like to work on expansion of the Kiosk idea to more locations. Vice-Chair, Maher, took this opportunity to discuss some problems that the CAP Manager had reported to him in regard to the Kiosk. Russian, Korean, and Chinese are currently not operational due to hardware and software problems. CAP Manager will keep vice-chair and language diversity committee updated on status of this issue. Ellen Murphy recommended that the panel consider meeting with an IRS National Office team that is designing the plans for future Kiosks. She can provide some names for the panel to contact. The panel agreed that a meeting would be appropriate. Staff to make arrangements for a meeting with the Language Diversity sub-committee and any other interested panel members.
  • Website - panel member Mihovich expressed some concerns with the effectiveness of our website. Asked how many hits we’ve had. (Staff will follow up and provide a monthly report). He suggested a section that talks about issues. Vice-chair Maher, who is on the website subcommittee, indicated that he has been working with a staff member on a "committee corner" that will accomplish this. When completed this will be shared with panel member Mihovich before posting to the website. Maher noted that our website is the most up to date of all four panels; however, the Pacific Northwest is very much in the forefront of using the threaded messaging site.

Procedures for CAP proposals

Staff member, Gita Hecht, gave a presentation and summary of the new procedures and provided the panel with copies of reports on the new tracking system. Copies of both of these items are attached and are an integral part of these minutes.

She also gave the panel information on the AMT for small businesses. A copy of that report is attached.

Town Hall Meeting

An issue was raised that the panel should start thinking about where to hold the May town hall meeting. The panel decided to pursue holding it in Manhattan. There was some discussion of possible neighborhoods and sites. The staff will confer with the marketing subcommittee as to next steps to pursue to find an appropriate site.

New Name

The panel decided to rename itself NEW YORK METRO CAP.

Guest

Joseph Noel was asked if he would like to say anything. He stated that he thought this was a great program. He thinks it might be helpful to have one or two practitioners in attendance at the meeting to bounce ideas off.

Adjournment

Panel member Mihovich made a motion to adjourn the meeting.

Panel member Cintron seconded the motion.

The meeting was adjourned at 9:20 PM

Attachments:

  • Calendar of Meetings
  • Report on proposal procedures
  • Report on current proposals
  • Report on AMT for small business

The Panel members accepted these minutes as written on February 9, 2001.

I hereby certify that, to the best of my knowledge, the foregoing minutes are accurate and complete.

 

 

 

Edward Maher - Chairperson

Brooklyn District Citizen Advocacy Panel